Powered by i.TV
September 30, 2014

Review: 'How I Met Your Mother' - 'The Perfect Week'

by Joel Keller, posted Feb 2nd 2010 12:02AM
Neil Patrick Harris and Jim Nantz in 'How I Met Your Mother' - 'The Perfect Week'
(S05E14)
Wouldn't everyone want to analyze their love lives with Jim Nantz?

Even if you haven't been as lucky in the sack as Barney Stinson, having an accomplished play-by-play guy talk about the ups and downs of your romantic escapades lends things a bit of gravitas and class.

However the 'HIMYM' writing team came up with the idea of how a nervous Barney recounts his perfect week in his own head, it was an inspired move, as it gave the episode the right narrative pull and really did put you in the position of a fan, pulling for him and making sure he didn't get jinxed. Did I just say that word?

Nantz was a pretty good sport; you don't usually see a guy at his level of blow-driedness spout phrases like "... and not a single fattie!" and not sound like he's in on the joke. Though all I could think of when Nantz delivered some of his more supportive lines was his divorce and his much-younger girlfriend. Ah, well. That just proves I read The Big Lead and Deadspin just too damn much.

There was something for every member of the 'Mother' gang this week; in fact, I wish at least a couple of the stories were better developed. Didn't you want to see more of Robin pining after the nerdy Smurf-loving date simply because he didn't call her back? Didn't you want to hear more about how it seemed like 4/5ths of the gang shared one toothbrush for the better part of a year -- and that Ted, Marshall and Lily accidentally shared one for eight? In fact, didn't you want to explore the whole "Marshall and Lily share a toothbrush and are OK with it?" storyline? Right, so did I.

The only story that didn't need to be explored any more than it did was Ted's torturing of poor Kuk Pu (or is is Kuk Poo?). It was a fun one-off joke and was treated as such. Though the Pu puns were pretty good: "She was down in the dumps." "You smeared the Pu name." "Did you get all the Pu out of your system?"

What all of it made for, though, was one hell of a bust-fest while the gang was watching Barney complete his perfect week. Watching the gang deflect at record rates was like watching a great ping-pong match; it was fast but fun to watch. Bays, Thomas and company have always been good at portraying the way friends bust on each other, and whenever one of those episodes come up, it's always fun to watch.

Back to Barney. The whole quest for the Perfect Week could be the Best Barneyism of the week, but I'm going to give it to a particular quote: "That woman nursing a Black Russian is about to chase it with a White American!"

Josh Radnor, Nick Swisher and Cobie Smulders in 'How I Met Your Mother' - 'The Perfect Week'More fun stuff:

  • What's interesting is that this was really less about how Barney seduced these seven women than how everyone reacted to it, especially when Nick Swisher's presence put the perfect week in danger. My favorite: Ted doing the catcher's scouting report and asking Barn to choose beteween the "heater," the "high and outside," or the "slider."
  • Swisher is a complete goofball. He always looks like he's enjoying himself, and it was fun as hell watching him on the Yankees this year. And he looked like a natural when he told the gang that sharing a toothbrush was a "sweet" thing for a couple to do. He may have an acting career in his future.
  • Love how Robin doesn't get the allure of baseball players -- "So, Mookie Wilson... is that a thing?" -- but hockey players would make her drop her panties "so hard, they'd fall through the floor and make a hole all the way to China." Maybe she'll hook up with the hockey-loving Swisher.
  • Nod to fans #1: Marshall saying "Sasquatch is real." We all know his love of Nessie and Sasquatch.
  • Nod to fans #2: After saying he and Lil needed to find a new couple after Ted broke up with Robin, Stella and Victoria, he said what we're all thinking: "Ted, jeez, when are you gonna get your life together?"
  • Nod to fans #3: Ted going, "Like I'm totally going to sit my kids down and talk to them about the time Barney nailed seven chicks in a row," and a smash cut to Old Ted asking his kids what we've all been thinking: "Am I a bad dad?"
  • The commemorative hats Marshall made say "Seven Up, Seven Down," which is fitting, since more than one baseball broadcaster has called a perfect game "27 up, 27 down."
  • Good to know Barney is keeping the job at GNB. Though seeing him try to find a job in this crummy economy would have been fun to watch.

[Watch clips and free episodes of 'HIMYM' at SlashControl.]

inputstring
channel: "CBS on AOL" show:how i met your mother sort:mostrecent
width
350
hidetitle
1

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

10 Comments

Filter by:
Jeff

"but I'd like to see Barney broke, suit free and trying to score on $5 a day. "

Challenge accepted.

Barney could develop a hidden camera reality TV show and sell it.

February 02 2010 at 11:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
GL

If Swish shows up in a bar in Chicago, some female Sox fan is liable to punch him in the jewels. From lame to game in one season. Good for him, I guess.

As for the rest, any episode that doesn't revolve around Ted is a home run for me.

February 02 2010 at 6:35 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
YesMan

Anyone know where I can get that Tie Barney is wearing during his interview with Jim Nantz?

February 02 2010 at 10:37 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
alk02g

I couldn't believe how poorly Ted handled having a student with a name like "Cook Pu." :( Ew on the toothbrush issue. Does that mean nobody ever bought a new one? Because you'd think that both Lily/Marshall and Ted would replace it every once in a while, and would somehow end up with 2 again. And I thought all of the baseball jokes (particularly Ted giving the pitching choices) were great.

February 02 2010 at 10:29 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
dkny

this is when the show is at it's best

February 02 2010 at 10:19 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Kristi

I really liked this episode of HIMYM, like you said it had some great moments for the fans referring to some of the favorite elements (themes, lines, etc) and it involved everyone in the cast in the best way. You had Barney in his glory, and you had the rest of the cast bouncing off each other to bring on the funny. I LOVE this show!
http://www.orble.com/teevee-how-i-met-your-mother-21/

February 02 2010 at 9:37 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Ryan

I thought this episode was structured really well and paced perfectly. Like you said, everyone had a storyline to latch on to in this episode and all of them just bouncing off one another is when HIMYM shines. BTW, I too loved the "nod to fans." Oh and it's spelled "Cook Pu" according to the subtitles I was reading...

February 02 2010 at 8:18 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Guess Who

Personally, I'd like to see a story arc where Barney loses his job and hits rock bottom. Predicable perhaps, but I'd like to see Barney broke, suit free and trying to score on $5 a day. If Barney could rise to the level of awesomeness, even without money, success or status it would be - legend...wait for it...dary.

February 02 2010 at 4:13 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rmpr

i don't care what Swisher says, sharing a toothbrush with a significant other is gross... You need to draw the line somewhere!

February 02 2010 at 1:07 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners