Three Reasons Why 'Lost' is the Greatest Show You'll Never Watch on DVD
Last night's episode of 'Lost' was excellent, wasn't it? For the first time this season it seems like we can finally see where the show is headed. The pieces are finally coming together. We don't know yet who is going to live or die (or even if "live" or "die" mean the same thing in this 'Lost' world) or what it ultimately all means, but last night was certainly a true turning point. Of course, the writers could still throw us a curve and we could find out that alternate-reality Desmond is actually a robot from the future obsessed with cheddar cheese, but it looks like the final handful of episodes will give us a real conclusion.
It's one of the greatest shows in TV history, and I'm probably never going to watch it on DVD.
Why?
1. It's too complex. This isn't a negative thing or an insult. I love that it's complex. But as for watching the show again on DVD, I don't know if that complexity will translate well. Sure, you could appreciate the acting in a particular episode, but you would actually have to watch several episodes that happened before that episode and maybe a few episodes after that episode to truly feel the full force of what the episode means.
To watch the show again on DVD you would have to actually commit to watching the entire series again, or at the very least an entire season. If that's something you can do, that's great. But it's not like other shows where you can watch an episode here and an episode there. Again, this isn't an insult. In fact, it speaks to the storytelling prowess of the writers more than anything else.
2. It has 70 characters and twelve timelines. I've seen every episode of 'Lost' and I truly love it, but even I get confused sometimes. What year are they in again? 2004? 1977? The 1950s? Who is that character again? How does that character fit into the series as a whole? Hey, is that the same guy who tried to kill the Oceanic castaways in season one? Was this person from 2004 on the island in the 50s? What does that book mean? Does that prop in the background have any significance? Did they explain that part already?
It can be a head-scratching (albeit a fun head-scratching) experience, and it's almost as if we have to say to ourselves, "wow, what a terrific story this show has weaved. Let's experience it once and then put it on the shelf."
3. If I'm reminded of the details, it might lose its power. I don't want to start watching the show from the beginning again and realize that plot developments and explanations that we got the final two seasons don't make ANY sense whatsoever. And I'm sure that with a show this complex that would be the case.
It's one of the reasons I don't want to go back to episodes in season one or season three when I have a question in this last season about a plot twist or an explanation the writers have given us. I'm just going to accept it, and if I revisit the show on DVD that acceptance might be in danger.
Note: this doesn't mean that I'm not going to buy the 'Lost' DVDs. In fact, I'll probably buy the inevitable 'Lost' Complete Series Super Mega-Set with Action Figures and Free Dharma Food when it comes out. I might not watch it but I certainly want to own it.

31 Comments