Powered by i.TV
May 19, 2013

'Lost' - 'What They Died For' Recap

by Jason Hughes, posted May 18th 2010 11:30PM
'Lost' - 'What They Died For'
(S06E16)
"I chose you because you needed the island as much as it needed you." -- Jacob

The penultimate episode of the entire series, the surviving castaways finally got some answers. And this time, they came directly from the horse's mouth -- no, I'm not talking about Kate's horse though that would have been surreal-ly awesome!

After last week's interlude where we got the full story (yeah, right!) of Jacob and the Man in Black, it was back to the survivors of Oceanic 815 on both sides of the reality divide. I guess it would be kind of obvious to say that both timelines are careening toward their inevitable climaxes. It's not like they have time to do much else.

ALPHA-VERSE (2007)

I never really liked Zoe anyway. After last week's bloodbath, I was expecting more bodies to fall in tonight's episode, but that was about it, unless we think Richard is dead. Personally, I'd find it hard to believe he's quite that easy to kill. I guess if the island no longer has a use for him, he could be dead, but I think the audience would rather witness Richard finally succumbing to death's embrace, where he can find the embrace of his long-lost wife.

Maybe that's one of the things in store for us in Sunday's massive two-and-a-half hour finale. Also ripe for death now, if I'm extrapolating correctly, are Kate, Sawyer and Hurley. After all, they were only being kept alive because they were still "Candidates." Now that Jack has accepted the job, they're all expendable.

It was a little quick and convenient the way Jack accepted the job. I was expecting a little bit more than Jacob offering it to all four of them, a moment of silence and then Jack saying, "I'll do it." Anti-climactic, isn't it? If it were that easy, Jacob should have asked him a few episodes ago before everyone had to die.

Also a little too convenient for my tastes was Jacob's explanation that he crossed Kate off the list because she had a child, but that it was just chalk on a wall and she could still take the job if she wanted it. At the same time, it could be a statement directly to the über-fans of the show. Sometimes things are just what they are and looking for some deeper meaning in them will bring only frustration.

In other words, we didn't make up what it all means, so some of it doesn't really mean anything. Is that good enough? Instead, we got little poetic moments like Jack sewing up Kate; a reversal of their roles in the pilot when she stitched him up. Another was when Richard revealed that he'd buried Alex after she was killed. Not pertinent to the over-all plot, but a little moment of human emotion from Ben.

It didn't really come as much of a surprise that Ben turned so quickly on Widmore and Zoe. For one, he doesn't stand a chance against the full might of MiB-Locke. For another thing, he was just promised the one thing he's been wanting all this time: the island all to himself. Too bad, MiB-Locke is a big liar. Or maybe he's more than willing to give Ben control of the smoldering remains of the island.

Wonder what would happen if the island were destroyed, considering it has that weird light at the center of it, and all those other electromagnetic properties. Would that energy disperse into the world at large?

BETA-VERSE (2004)

In the beta-verse, the island has apparently already been destroyed, considering it's at the bottom of the sea. There don't appear to be any long-term affects of its absence -- perhaps because there is no Smoke Monster in the beta-verse. If Jacob did truly create the Smoke Monster by pushing the Man in Black's body into the light, then what was their "other mother" doing? What was her job on the island?

Jacob described his job as being the guardian of the island, and keeping the Man in Black from the light. But that can't have been her job, so was it to protect the island from outsiders? She was certainly keen to kill anyone who came onto the island, whereas Jacob allowed the island to be literally crawling with outsiders. Outsiders who couldn't perceive the cave and the light anyway, so what danger did they pose. I have a feeling the "other mother" is a pile of questions we won't be getting answers for.

At least we should get some clarification as to what Desmond's plan is. I was a little disappointed we didn't get to see alpha-Desmond this week as I would have liked to see if they were both perhaps working toward the same angle. Can I just say that it was hilariously appropriate that Desmond was able to trigger beta-Ben's memories of the island by punching the crap out of him. Considering alpha-Ben has spent 90 percent of his time on the show with his face getting smashed in, it's incredibly fitting.

Beta-Desmond shifted his tactics to Sayid and Kate, springing them from jail by greasing the hands of Ana Lucia, who's "not ready" for whatever he has planned. Now we're as close as we can be to what that plan is, and I still can't figure it out. Why is he now directly interacting with these three; he's recruited Hurley as well?

Was getting Locke to go to Jack for that spinal surgery all Desmond needed to accomplish there? If Desmond and Kate are going to the concert, where are Hurley and Sayid going? The way they've been setting things up, it looks like a lot of people connected to the island will be there. Does Desmond need to kill them all? Punch them in the face?

How can we get from here to whatever the end game is ... and it had better not be a close-up of Jack's eye as he wakes up and realizes it was all a dream. Or Bob Newhart's eye for that matter.

No, on second thought, if it's Bob Newhart, that would be hilarious.

[Catch up on all you missed, except for sleep, with clips and full episodes of 'Lost' over at SlashControl.]

Follow @ultraversion21 on Twitter.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

54 Comments

Filter by:
RAY CUEVAS

All I can say is...this series better not end up like 'the Sopranos' did...

May 22 2010 at 1:11 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
sowhatsupbaby

I remember that Desmond was referred to as a "constant" in relation to Faraday's work. Also, Faraday's mother said that "the island wasn't done with him yet" We have yet to see Faraday's mother (Witmore's wife) They will all meet once again so that Faraday can complete his experiments and put them all together in the same time zone. Sideways, forwards, backwards, dead or alive in the present.

As for Richard, I was not happy how they ended his role.

May 19 2010 at 11:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
sowhatsupbaby

I will relaly miss this show. It really kept us concentrating and using our imaginative minds. It was different and a breath of fresh air when comparing it to all the MSI Crime and Forensic shows and all the "reality" garbage that is on TV.

I hope they make it into a movie.

May 19 2010 at 11:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
sowhatsupbaby

When MIB killed his second mother, she "thanked him" for it. I believe she was glad to end her looking after the island, which she passed on to Jacob. Now she was from the Roman times and spoke Latin and their real mother spoke in Spanish.

May 19 2010 at 11:10 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
sowhatsupbaby

I also believe that Jack's wife at the concert is Juliet. Just look at the son's blue eyes. They are exactly like hers.

May 19 2010 at 11:04 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Linda

I don't agree with u on several fronts:
1) That Jack accepted so quickly was so fitting. How many times have we heard him say that he had a purpose on the island and he wasn't leaving? Remember Sawyer inviting him off the boat? It was exactly as it should have been and that it was done quickly gave credence to that. Kudos to the script buildups (and acting) that prepared us for that moment.
2) As a mom, I cried when he told Kate she was off the list because she was a mother. I'm not the only one who felt that way (read all the boards). It was one of those moments you just get it; from a child who had a conflicted mother and a murdered mother, it made sense that motherhood was held in high esteem.
3) I believe Robert is dead. The suddenness of it, wrapped in un-Locke's rage, made us brutally aware of the stakes at play; this, indeed, is it.
4) Ben is not interested in running the island. He found his redemption in accepting the enormity of his loss. His alt-verse story parallels that. Ben is doing what Sayid did; finding redemption through that last act of saving the others.
5) It was important to show the burial site of Alex. It happened quickly, briefly, and reminded us of the long relationship Ben had with Richard; and that despite the crap that happened, Richard had the heart to do for Ben's daughter what needed to be done. It also gave us that quick reminder before Ben said to Ben: "He doesn't get to save his daughter."

May 19 2010 at 4:53 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Linda's comment
mrsj

Who is is Robert(#3)? Did you mean Richard?

May 19 2010 at 5:35 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
cruella

Thank the Lord I didn't watch this mess. What a waste of time.

May 19 2010 at 4:35 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to cruella's comment
mrsj

But you think posting here about a show you didn't even watch and know nothing about is a valuable use of your time?

May 19 2010 at 5:37 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Andrew

Jack accepting it was too easy and as Jacob said "It's yours for as long as you want it", what if in the end there's a twist and Sawyer ends up asking to take the job from Jack, after all that has happened to him. I don't see Hurley or Kate being the protector.

May 19 2010 at 1:35 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Melanie51

At this point, I just want Desmond and Penny to live happily ever after. If Sawyer & Juliet reunite, it'll be a big bonus.

May 19 2010 at 1:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
LS

Desmond called Jack to say that his father's body had been found. What if the MIB has taken over Christian's body and is now off the island in the beta-verse?
It is obvious that they will all reunite at the concert where Daniel Faraday (musician not scientist) is.
I can't wait until Sunday!

May 19 2010 at 1:08 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners