When Amy didn't get picked to be a bridesmaid on 'True Beauty' (Mon., 10PM ET on ABC), she broke down sobbing. "I never thought I'd be this miserably bad at something," she said. Judge Carson Kressley could relate, saying, "I feel her pain: 8th grade gym class. Hello. Never picked ever."

As she sat there weeping, another contestant grabbed a tissue. But instead of offering it to Amy, he used it to wipe his sweaty brow. "Amy's distraught. It's unfortunate, but you know what, I'm not here to console her. I'm here to compete -- it's as simple as that," he said.

But he doesn't know it's an inner-beauty competition. And the judges saw the whole thing on the hidden cameras. Not so simple after all.