Powered by i.TV
February 10, 2012
 
CONNECT    

'America's Got Talent' - 'Episode 512' Vegas Week Recap

by Isabelle Carreau, posted Jul 8th 2010 1:14AM
America's Got Talent(S05E12) "We're gonna end up sending home a superstar." - Howie

Sadly, I'm pretty sure Howie is right. Not only did they probably send a superstar home, but they sent a few more questionable acts to the Top 48.

One novelty though, the judges were able to stick to the predetermined number of 48 acts going through to Hollywood. Usually, they are so unable to decide that they add an act or two.

Time to review the final Vegas Week performances!

Danger

- 'Power Rangers'-in-the-making Kung Fu Heroes once again offered us a flawless and professional kung fu act.

- The knife thrower, Nick Pike, and Jeremy, all upped their game and offered acts that were daring, entertaining and somewhat frightening to watch. Nick's craziness entertained me more. Juggling with a flamed torch and two huge knives while having a hood over his head and walking on sharp pieces of broken glass sprinkled with gasoline was surely his most dangerous act.

Kid Dance

- Both dance troupes offered once again solid performances. However, RNG's routine seemed a bit too similar to their audition with just different outfits.

Vocal Groups

- Sadly, we saw very few of the vocal groups perform. New Directions Veterans Choir's performance featured great vocals and harmonies but their performance was probably not flashy enough for the judges' taste.

- Sisters Christina and Ali gave it their all again this week. For girls who were told they could never sing, they do have some fantastic pipes!

Novelty acts

- The finished product of Erin Barylski's painting act was not that good -- the judges had to ask her what it was! When comparing her act to painter Maricar, at least the latter's moves as she paints are a bit more entertaining.

- I'm really impressed that Rick Smith Jr. can actually cut/break things by throwing playing cards. They must have extremely sharp edges, no? Sadly for Rick, he couldn't get that last balloon to pop, which had the judges freak out a bit as they were afraid they would get injured by the rather close-to-them balloon.

- I can't believe that Ronith changed his act totally just because Piers didn't like his audition. But what I can't understand is why the judges put him through, as his Vegas sketch was NOT why he was put through to Vegas, plus it wasn't really funny. He was better at impressions ... even if he wasn't that great at that either.

Bands

- We didn't see many of the bands perform. From the quick montage we've seen, the violinists playing 'Bad Romance' seemed really good. Harmonik sounded a bit off, especially when their lead singer was singing the long notes in 'You Raise Me Up.' Their performance was not as magical and entertaining as their audition.

- I really don't get Airpocalypse. Their act was fun once, but twice it's too much. What they do is not a talent.

Male singers

- Nick and the judges were right when saying that the male singers category was the biggest and most competitive one. All singers in this group gave good performances. It was surely not an easy choice to make.

And the remaining 11 spots are taken by ...

- Kung Fu Heroes
- Jeremy, bicycle daring act
- RNJ
- Luigi, singer
- Nathaniel, singer
- Ronith, impersonation
- The band with the blond female singer
- Airpocalypse
- One solo singer
- Christina and Ali, singers
- Another group

This time, I'm questioning having Ronith and Airpocalypse being part of the Top 48. Now that the power lies in our hands, America, it's time to first vote off the acts that are the worst. Please don't vote for underdogs or bad acts just because you want them to have a few votes. Vote for quality so that we have a Top 5 that rocks!

[Follow @icarreau on Twitter]

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

4 Comments

Filter by:
Sashi

I only started watching AGT this year, mostly because my roommate and his girlfriend watch it, and my fiance and I work in the living room when it's on. After Tuesday, I'll work in another room! For a show that bills itself as a 'Talent' competition, to put through the 'comedian' magician and the 10 minute performance by a lady who couldn't carry a tune in a bucket (or that hair) while turning away excellent singers and dancers and threatening others with DQing for being 45 seconds over was, frankly, offensive. My fiance has started calling it "America's got Schtic" or "Howie and Sharon have no taste" and I'm going to have to agree.

Some of the performers are excellent, and I wish them luck, but I just can't support a show that assumes it's audience are idiots who can't tell the difference between good and bad.

July 08 2010 at 4:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Sashi's comment
liz

There seems to be some confusion here . Well some acts were entertaining there is no way they will make it past the semis who is going to watch someone hand whistle for an hour . I agree too many very talented singers dancers and other acts were cut .
Maybe they need to have two shows one for acts that people might like to see again and another for those who have enough talent to win

July 09 2010 at 1:49 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rob

My theory is that a few clangers were put through to the Final 48 in order to ensure that the producers' preferred acts actually survive the early voting.

If all 48 acts were good, there might have been some upsets... and how can we have our desired results if the public vote for the wrong people????

And does anyone believe that Piers, Sharon, and Howie make the casting decisions alone? Of course not. The dog-and-pony show on the podium is staged, and has nothing to do with the casting decisions.

July 08 2010 at 8:58 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
MARY

OMG, what poor choices this time. The opera singer from PR was terrific, first big dumb mistake. Second and third big dumb mistakes were the two elderly women; one used her hands to make sounds, the other with the red hair and awful clown makeup who stayed on stage forever - what were the judges thinking? It was a real joke having them on to begin with. And the non-instrument trio - what was the joke even considering them. There are a few others that were good, but definitely NOT worthy of going to Hollywood. If the winner gets a gig in Vegas, that act must be able to hold the attention of the audience for at least 45 minutes - riding a bike (no matter how dangerous and good an act) does not count. I'd have to review the entire contest to continue writing, but that I refuse to take the time to do. As far as I am concerned, this year's choices leave a lot to be desired. And I miss the Hoff, too.

July 08 2010 at 8:03 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners