Powered by i.TV
May 23, 2013

Offbeat Emmy Surprises: The Most Nominated Person in History Is ... (You'll Never Guess)

by Gary Susman, posted Jul 8th 2010 4:00PM
old spice adThis morning's Emmy nominations went more or less as expected, but with a few really strange surprises.

Some were huge (the TV Academy's recognition of Conan O'Brien's 'Tonight Show' and not Jay Leno's was a jaw-dropper).

Some were small but still worth mentioning, including nominations for some unlikely but deserving performers, as well as interesting nominations in categories I didn't even know existed.

Here are 10 of the strangest surprises among this year's Emmy nominees.

1. It's the Old Spice guy vs. Betty White in the Battle of the Ads. We didn't even know they gave out Emmys for Outstanding Commercial. This year's nominees include Betty White's Super Bowl ad for Snickers and the Old Spice ad 'The Man Your Man Could Smell Like' that made a star out of the impossibly dashing Isaiah Mustafa. (I'd give the edge to Old Spice. White's spot was hilarious, but Mustafa's actually made me want to go out and buy the product.)

H. Jon Benjamin2. Finally, some Emmy love for H. Jon Benjamin
. Benjamin, who voices the lead role of suave, mama's-boy secret agent Sterling Archer on FX's hilarious 'Archer,' has been doing unseen yeoman's work for nearly two decades as a voiceover actor in cartoons for grown-ups, as a regular cast member or frequent guest on such shows as 'Dr. Katz, Professional Therapist,' 'Home Movies,' 'Aqua Teen Hunger Force,' 'The Venture Bros.' and 'Family Guy.' On 'Archer,' Benjamin's is the least famous name in a cast that includes Jessica Walter, Aisha Tyler, Chris Parnell and Judy Greer. Still, his alternately lackadaisical and frantic delivery holds the show together, so it's great that the TV Academy finally gave him his first Emmy nomination today, for Outstanding Voiceover Performance. According to his IMDb profile, his personal quote is: "If you do nothing long enough, something's bound to happen." Well, there you go.

3. 'Glee' outscores 'Mad Men.' 'Glee' is great, but is it really a better show than 'Mad Men'? The Academy seems to think so; it gave the freshman choral comedy 19 nominations, while the perennial Emmy favorite took 17. Maybe they could have earned two or three more nods if Don and Betty occasionally broke into song.

4. 'Family Guy' gets a nod for controversial 'Down's Syndrome Girl.' Remember the February episode of 'Family Guy' whose throwaway joke by a character with Downs Syndrome (she said her mother was the former governor of Alaska) threw Sarah Palin and her minions into a week-long fit of rage? The Academy does, and it recognized that episode for its even more potentially offensive highlight, Stewie's dubious tribute to the character, his song-and-dance number 'Down's Syndrome Girl.' Better not tell Team Palin that the tune, composed by 'Family Guy' creator Seth MacFarlane and Walter Murphy, earned a nomination for Outstanding Original Music and Lyrics.

'Down's Syndrome Girl' from 'Family Guy'


5. Sharon Gless returns to Emmy glory. Gless is no stranger to the Emmys. In the 1980s, she was nominated six times in a row for 'Cagney & Lacey' and won twice. (Before today, she'd earned nine career nominations.) Her 'Burn Notice' character, spy mom Madeline Westen, wasn't on most people's Emmy short lists, but she is the funny, sweet moral center of the tongue-in-cheek action show, which, up until now, has only earned two nominations in technical categories. It's good to see Gless, and the show, get a major nomination, in the Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama category.

6. 'The Kennedy Center Honors' and 'American Idol' get six nominations each.
The annual special honoring performers who've spent a lifetime demonstrating their talents tied with the amateur karaoke contest. Just sayin'.

7. They give Emmys to websites? Yes they do, only they call the prize Outstanding Achievement in Interactive Media, and they divide it into two categories, for websites affiliated with fiction and non-fiction shows. This year, the Academy liked the websites for 'The Biggest Loser,' 'Late Night with Jimmy Fallon' and 'Top Chef' (for non-fiction) and 'Dexter,' 'Glee,' and 'Star Wars: Uncut' (for fiction). I imagine the trophies will go to 'Glee' (because the website actually helped the show make a ton of money via music downloads) and 'Late Night' (because Fallon is expert at making short comedy bits that go viral as embeddable videos).

Andre Braugher in 'Men of a Certain Age'8. Andre Braugher catches a break.
Which is more than you can say for his character on 'Men of a Certain Age.' He plays Owen, a man closing in on 50 who's done everything by the book, but for whom nothing has gone as he planned. The best he feels he can hope for is to endure his lot with stoic reserve. It's the least showy performance on the series; Ray Romano's more desperate dad is the biggest stretch, as it has very little in common with his comic 'Everybody Loves Raymond' persona, and it's the one that seemed likeliest to earn an Emmy nod. Braugher merely does quietly excellent work, as he always has, the kind that has earned him five nominations and one win before today. Neither he nor his show had a tremendous amount of buzz going into this race, so his nomination as Best Supporting Actor in a Drama is a nice surprise.

9 .'Undercover Boss' is nominated for Outstanding Reality Program. Really?

10. Hector Ramirez becomes the most nominated person in Emmy history.
What, you've never heard of Hector Ramirez? He's a cameraman, and he's been nominated 60 times in the past 33 years, including five times today. He's a member of the nominated camera crews for 'Dancing With the Stars,' the 25th annual Rock and Roll Hall of Fame concert, and this year's Oscar, Grammy, and Kennedy Center Honors ceremonies. He's won 15 times in his 55 previous nominations, so with that batting average, he's likely to score at least one more trophy this year. Go Hector!



•Follow Gary Susman on Twitter @garysusman.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

12 Comments

Filter by:
Suzy

Although I don't watch daytime television anymore, I used to when I was at home a few years ago. I will
never forget how many times Susan Lucci who acts as the witchy yet beautiful Erica Kane on All My
Children, for the last 25 years, or something like
that. She was nominated at least 15 times, then she finally won. I forget exactly what year she won, but it was a huge surprise for her and for her fans, I'm sure. Everyone thought it was some "curse," but that curse has been broken finally!

July 14 2010 at 12:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
R Brown

Hugh Laurie deserves the Emmy award. He has the unique distinction, among all of the Drama Actor nominees, of having done work in drama that is amazing enough to be nominated by Emmy for the Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series Award, for FIVE YEARS - 2005, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010.

It's about getting the opportunity to do good work, but it is also about consistent excellence.

This season's opener "Broken" won the Writers' Guild of America's Television Award for Episodic Drama, and Hugh was in front of the camera over 90% of the time in that episode. Even the best writing for the screen needs an exceptional actor to interpret it. HUGH LAURIE IS THAT ACTOR, AND IT'S ABOUT TIME.

July 11 2010 at 8:16 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
John

That's pretty sick. The 'Down's Syndrome Girl' song is about a pedophile who is enamored with a Down's Syndrome child and what he would like to do to her. Typical Hollywood.

July 10 2010 at 1:54 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jenny K.

Don and Betty didn't, but the episode "My Old Kentucky Home" had singing (Roger/Paul/Joan), dancing (Pete/Trudy), and accordion-playing (Joan). So, Mad Men should have at least tied Glee for nominations.

July 09 2010 at 11:42 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Leroy

Betty White's other nomination it the one that concerns me, the one that puts her up against Jane Lynch. How can doing a few skits on one episode of SNL equal creating a great, complex character over 18 episodes? I hope the voters don't let they love of Betty outweigh Jane's great work.

July 09 2010 at 12:17 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Leroy's comment
Shane Harrison

That Jane Lynch nomination is for her work on "Two and a Half Men," not "Glee." I think I can live with her not getting that one.

July 09 2010 at 2:34 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Gordy

Betty White is a bioch, so I'll go with Old Spice.

July 08 2010 at 6:55 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
BC McKinney

3. They're in different categories, up against different competitors. The number of noms is not a measure of the shows to each other.

July 08 2010 at 6:11 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
LRM

The real shocker for me is that John Noble did not get nominated.

July 08 2010 at 5:24 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Tony DIMeo

I saw a few episodes of MEN of certain age and Andre Braugher gives scene stealing performances in each episode Im glad to see him nominated But Aaron Paul deserves the win

July 08 2010 at 5:09 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners