Easy to understand. He is involved in both shows and they are sister shows

With the abscence of Paula the show lost its excitement. The addition of Ellen was just a fizzle. She added NOTHING to the show, in fact, her comments were like "duh? - ". There were times I fell asleep during the show, and gradually just stopped watching it altogether. In my opinion, the only one w/ any talent was the girl that sang country and played the Guitar. With Simon leaving I probably wont even bother to watch it at all. A shame to "fix something that wasnt broken".

OMG- And the Republicans want to run this guy for President? How low can they sink?

I have come to the realization that no matter what happens if he goes to AI or not. Idol is a dissapointing scam. After watching the first round of auditions (cattle call) it was apparent and confirmed by people working there, that Idol is NOT a talent competition it is a reality show. After witnessing some amazing singers getting passed on for people in Riddler costumes or a twinking fairy with a giant toothbrush, it really damaged what I thought about it and if it were to end. Good riddance!

haha! i watched that last night and when he said "American Idol" im like WHAT? im pretty sure this is NOT "american Idol". haha i just got on and saw the headline and im iike, i remember that....it was like it just happend yesterday. oh wait it did hapeen yesterday.

A terrific show with talented young dancers, all of which make it hard to chose a winner. Jose does show his lack of dance training, especially when pitted alongside Kent BUT kudos to him for determination, hard work and a gallant effort for everything thrown at him. Sadly I think he will be one of the outs tonight. Robert emerges as a very mature dancer who put Billy to second with the arduous Bollywoood routine. Laura is an incredible young dancer. If I could change the judges panel I would send Mia Michaels packing despite her credentials. Her flakiness and ultra BS is now as annoying as Mary's big mouth!

This is the best season yet for two reasons: They finally got rid of the most annoying judge - Mary Murphy - and her awful screeching and they finally got mostly excellent dancers 9 out of 11 (tap girl and salsa girl were not good enough and rightly the first to go). I have enjoyed watching truly excellent dancers. Time for Jose to go though.

Well I don't like Nigel and I don't watch the show.
But I am a big fan of American Idol.
I don't know if I keep watching AI if they replace the judges, I still have to recover from the loss of Paula and Simon --- The only original Judges.

Get rid of Nigel!

He looks like he raised his hand and said yep I swallow.lol