Powered by i.TV
May 27, 2012

'Angry' Mia Michaels Says Claims of 'Dance' Racism Are Ridiculous

by PopEater Staff, posted Aug 10th 2010 8:20PM
Mia Michaels and AdéChiké Torbert from So You Think You Can Dance
'So You Think You Can Dance' judge Mia Michaels is fighting back against charges of racism that have broken out on blogs since last week's elimination of AdéChiké Torbert (right). Specifically, critics have made remarks to the effect that she has it in for black male dancers.

"It's just ridiculous, honestly. I actually Twittered because there was so much negativity coming at me, because they think I was coming at him for really stupid reasons," she told PopEater's Stacy Jenel Smith. "I had to make clear that I as a judge, as a person, don't care what somebody looks like. I could care less what color their skin is, or how big they are, what their weight is. I look at their performance. I look at their integrity as an artist. I look at their technicality. I look strictly at that. People are trying to find something that isn't there. They're digging into the wrong areas."
Michaels admitted that such comments have made her feel "kind of angry because like, I want to tell them, 'You don't know me. You don't know me at all.' I mean, without getting, you know -- it's just, my friends, my boyfriends, my dancers. Some of the finest dancers that have worked for me are black men and my assistants are black men. People are trying to grab at anything to make a reason why I'm critiquing him as harsh as I do and, it's -- I keep getting this rap, I don't like black male dancers, and anybody who knows me knows that's just hilarious. We crack up."

She mentioned boyfriends. So Michaels has dated black men?

"Yes, I mean, years ago I was engaged to an African American, actually, a Cuban guy," she replied. "I'm open to people. I'm looking for the spirit. I'm looking for the art. I don't care if they're purple green with polka dots. I'm so much deeper than that."

The Emmy-winning choreographer, who has worked with such stars as Madonna, Prince, Celine Dion and Ricky Martin, said of herself, Nigel Lithgoe and Adam Shankman, "As judges, clearly -- clearly -- we've been doing this so long. I started dancing when I was three, started choreographing when I was 15. I've been doing this my entire life and I know what I'm looking at. And what I say, it's an opinion; people can take it or leave it. It's not the bible of dance. For me, AdéChiké was not one of the stronger dancers from the get-go. I honestly don't think he would have been around as long as he was if we hadn't had all the injuries we had this season."

Nevertheless, she stressed that she believes he's a good dancer and "a great young man. He's very strong, an athlete, but he needs a lot of work in the fluidity department and style. He needs to tap into the artistry and the style of dancing."
Michaels, who wants to continue in her role as judge on the hugely-popular Fox show -- which has its season finale episodes Wednesday and Thursday this week -- said, "I've learned a lot, too.

"I've learned that words are very, very important and you have to choose wisely. That's something I've learned this season -- I need to be careful how I deliver my thoughts on a performance and a person. I would by no means ever want to hurt somebody just for the sake of hurting somebody. I would never, ever want that. So when I had come across very harsh on AdéChiké one week, I really took a step back. That was a real learning curve for me and I needed to apologize to him, and I did. I said, 'I'm really sorry if I hurt you or offended you in any way. That was not my intention.'"

Michaels also spoke to AdéChiké after his elimination, she said, and, as anyone would expect, he was disappointed not to make the finale. "But I also told him that he should be very happy, that he should be celebrating that he had gone so far. He's going to do great."

And now the attention turns to the three finalists -- Kent Boyd, Lauren Froderman and Robert Roldan -- one of whom is soon to be named this season's winner.

"You're going to see them at top form for the finale. You know, everybody at the end is just going to go for broke, like really bust a move," Michaels predicts. "They each bring something different. Robert is this humble sweetheart. Kent is the farm boy. And Luaren is this little girl who is like the diva, because she's the only girl standing. I think it's just a personal preference at this point. For me, I would be happy if any one of them won."

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

16 Comments

Filter by:
B. Fubara

I have stopped watching So You Think You Can Dance.
It was not so much that Adechike was eliminated, it was the so obvious way the judges made it known at the very first second of the show, that was the one they thought should be eliminated. The criticism was relentless right from the beginning of the hour. I thought it was hysterical the way Cat Deely was claiming that the judges would have no part in the decision making.They left nothing to chance in making sure that he was eliminated!

August 11 2010 at 8:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Candice

Mia is such a talented dancer and choreographer. Her opinions are just that, opinions. I happen to agree with her opinions of Ade and don't see them as racist or harsh.

August 11 2010 at 8:10 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dave

Anything and I mean anything that does not go their way, they loose at something, don't get that job, are arrested, stopped for speeding. It is because they are black. well most are now tired of the same whinning. It now seems if they are brown or black. You may get the race card attack !

August 11 2010 at 5:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Johan

It's "I COULDN'T CARE LESS", damn it!!

August 11 2010 at 2:12 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
sassyy2009

I've never thought Mia was racist, but I thought she was biased against masculine, strong men. I was really shocked to read that she's had boyfriends. Honestly thought she really only liked the gay dancers. I'm not aware of any implicit bias in any of the other judges (including Mary) I've always really disliked Mia, thought she was terribly rude and said some pretty personal, hurtful things that had little to do with dance but attacked their personalities. I would like to see her replaced, but don't think she should be wrongly smeared with racism. I would like to see Mary come back, crazy peals of laughter be damned....

August 11 2010 at 12:34 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
2 replies to sassyy2009's comment
RobynM

You're not alone in your opinion of Mia. She's always come across to me as mean-spirited, overly personal, and Extremely biased in favour of Lyrical and Contemporary dancers. In fact, it's gotten so bad that when my friends and I watch the show, we DVR it and completely skip over the judges' commentary. I don't think any of us would be terribly disappointed if Mary came back to replace her. But yeah, racism isn't on the list of things I'd accuse her of.

August 11 2010 at 8:37 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dan

I think that Mia is overly critical because she's one of those people who was told she was too fat to dance and she wants to take out her anger on others.

They were clearly biased against Adechike, though I don't think it was for racism necessarily...but the one main piece of evidence for this bias was when they told Adechicke and Jose conflicting things and Cat called them out for it. They praised Jose for allowing his personality into his Bollywood routine when they reamed Adechike for the same thing.

I do think the show itself can generally be a bit racist. Any time a hip-hop number is danced, it's "dirty, grimy and dark".

Finally, just because someone dated a black man once does not mean they harbor resentment towards them. She said "years ago I was engaged to an African-American, actually a Cuban guy"...meaning he probably broke her heart and she harbors resentment towards men who remind her of him. Plus, calling a Cuban man "African-American" is ignorant and clearly a sign of someone not comfortable saying "black". Black people are not offended by being called "black" unless there is a negative tone or it's clear the person is uncomfortable saying it. Calling a black Cuban "African-American" is like calling someone from Spain a Mexican...

August 11 2010 at 11:36 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
smays75

I believe she is and Nigel

August 11 2010 at 12:32 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
smays75

I believe she is and Nigel, I will not be watching AI if he is a judge.They turn me off om Do You Think You can dance use to love the show I hate it now that woman and Nigel

August 11 2010 at 12:29 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
CC

I don't think Mia Michaels is racist, or any of her critiques on the show were racist. You could tell that she was not a fan of AdeChike, but it had to do with his dancing*, not with the color of his skin.

I say dancing with an asterik because I think the judges also look for personality. For AdeChike, who comes across as a bit quiet, judges always tear them apart. They did the same thing to Alex at the beginning of the show, and have in the past with other dancers. Having been a dancer (ballet), I don't care if a dancer has "personality" - we want to see the dancing, not the facial expressions. But considering this is about America's "favorite" dancer, I guess the judges want to see personality. And they apparently think a class clown like Robert is better than a quiet person like AdeChike (or seemingly quiet, since we don't know what he's like away from the stage).

August 10 2010 at 10:20 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
3 replies to CC's comment
replicasky

That's a great show

August 10 2010 at 9:50 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
skeeree

Wow! I thought it was just me. I watched this episode and none of the judges had anything good to say about Torbert. They gave alot of air time and lavished attention on the blonde girl (of course). I could see the hurt on his face. Anyway, while thought I would begin tuning in to this program again begininng with this episode. Instead, I have vowed never to watch this again.

August 10 2010 at 9:38 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners