'Persons Unknown' Series Finale Recap
(Season 1, Episode 13 - 'Shadows in the Cave') Shortly before 'Persons Unknown' ended, I tweeted this:"Oh, for God's sake." #PersonsUnknown
NBC, I think, lied to us a little bit, didn't they? They promised us that "at the end of the summer, all of our questions will be answered," or something like that. But this wasn't a series-ender, it was a season-ender! Nothing really got resolved.
Sure, we got a lot of answers and we know what's going on, but this didn't end the story, it was actually the start of a potentially intriguing second season.
I can sense fans across the country gritting their teeth. That probably started with five or six minutes left in the series, when our group woke up in the damn hotel again. You knew where this was going, an ending that really wasn't an ending, and you probably exhaled in exasperation. It's not that it wasn't a "good" ending -- it would have been a terrific, even logical, season one cliffhanger -- it just wasn't a good series ending, especially since we were promised closure. The network seemed to go out of its way to tell us that because they know that we've been screwed over before.
Or maybe they just said that so we'd watch it.
It was a juggling act, that's for sure. We actually got a lot of answers and kinda knew what was going on -- the Madame Director, that mysterious board, the prison camp, how it was all an experiment, Janet's mom being involved, etc -- but at the same time this episode not only didn't give us closure, it actually started the whole series over with the same group of people (and some new people, like Mark). So they set up a second season of the show, one that looked rather interesting, with two different groups, Kat and the ambassador in the prison, etc, but we all know it's not coming. Ever.
This doesn't affect my enjoyment of the series as a whole. It's not like the show ended in a confusing fade to black or a scenario where it was all a dream or something like that. The characters are alive -- even Tori! -- they're just in places that give us no closure. But what a second season it could be! Half of the group (Joe, Mark, a bunch of newbies) back in the town and half of the group (Janet, Charlie, Blackham, Erika, a robotic Graham, and Moira) on some giant ship in the middle of the ocean with the original concierge. A "Level 2" that makes the whole thing seem like a video game.
So I didn't completely hate the finale. It made me believe that a second season of this show was actually possible, something I didn't believe when the show began. I just wish it was a season-ender and not the end of the story.
More thoughts (and questions):
• How exactly did the gang get separated after the van crash, Janet in San Francisco, Graham on the table, and Erika and Moira in Morocco? Seems like some jumbled continuity there.
• How did Blackham know the name of Charlie's wife, and why was it brought up in the last episode?
• Why did Mark and Kat run when they saw Gomez and the cops? You would think he'd trust Gomez at this point.
• I did like how Mark and Janet finally saw each other. It reminded me that she didn't even know this whole time that he was trying to find her.
• Why did Janet go home? Sure, she wanted to get back home and see Megan, but wouldn't you assume that both the secret organization and the police would go there first to look for her? But they never did.
• How exactly did everyone end up back at the hotel and on the boat? They seemed to completely skip over that rather important point. Maybe they were going to cover that in the second season.
• I'm not sure I understand the title of this episode.
How would I have ended this show? Glad you asked. Since it was very clear weeks and weeks ago that NBC wasn't going to renew the show, I would have gone back into the editing room and cut off the ending. If they couldn't reshoot a scene or two I would have just had it ended with the revelation that the gang had staged the murders, escaped, and had convinced Gomez and others what was going on. They didn't even have to show the bad guys being "defeated," they could have just shown the gang alive and their story being believed. There would have been more story to tell, sure, but it still would have been satisfying, a la that alternate ending to the original 'Invasion of the Body Snatchers' where Kevin McCarthy convinces the authorities about the alien invasion.
I think fans would have liked the ambiguous ending a bit more if we weren't promised answers all summer. But we were so it just wasn't satisfying. Still, overall, a fun, clever show, with the promise of a cool second season that could have been.
| It was great, just like the rest of this show. | |
|---|---|
| It was OK, but I was expecting more closure. | |
| I'm never trusting another TV show again. |
[Follow Bob on Twitter.]

35 Comments