Powered by i.TV
May 27, 2012
TV's Best Video Clips - Updated Daily

'The Big C' Season 1, Episode 4 Recap (VIDEO)

by Laura Prudom, posted Sep 14th 2010 7:30AM
['The Big C' - 'Playing the Cancer Car']

While the previous three episodes of 'The Big C' have been solid, quirky and occasionally brilliant, episode four was truly a delight to watch -- nothing's quite as much fun as seeing a character being positively gleeful on TV these days, and Laura Linney was shining like a beacon as she frolicked joyfully from one unpredictable situation to the next.

For most people, a cherry red convertible is a sure-fire sign of a mid-life crisis -- which is exactly what Cathy's behavior seems like to the untrained eye -- but for a woman who's not sure she'll even live to see the end of mid-life, it seems like a sound investment.

There was an irrepressible lightness to this week's installment (despite the ever-lurking shadow of Cathy's condition on the horizon -- much like the storm at the end of the episode), from Cathy's playful interactions with her scene-stealing brother, to her role-playing as Dr. Todd's cougar girlfriend.

Cathy and her dreamy doctor have certainly crossed the line from doctor/patient to almost-friends, and seeing the pair banter and improvise their way through an unlikely house showing was excellent comedy, since it seemed as though even Cathy had no idea what she might say next.

Yet even in its most hilarious moments, the show seems to be capable of effortlessly dialing back the absurdity for moments of quiet reflection, as Cathy related to the plight of the poor lobster at the seafood restaurant, minding its own business on the sea bed before getting caught in a trap and served for dinner. Watching her free the creature in the salt-water pool was especially poignant, especially when our tragic heroine jumped in fully clothed to float in the water and imagine that time was standing still.

One thing that always strikes me about Linney's performance is how energetic she is -- at times I almost felt exhausted just from watching her ramble and gesticulate; it makes me wonder if it's a conscious effort on her part to brim with life and exuberance in every scene, when the first couple of episodes showed Cathy as very tense and repressed. As she slowly comes to terms with her condition, perhaps this freewheeling euphoria will continue: It's certainly an improvement over Nagging Cathy.

No discernible changes on obnoxious watch: Both Paul and Adam are still being insufferable, but it seems as if the omnipresent Marlene (Phyllis Somerville) has a plan for whipping Adam back into shape with a little healthy blackmail. It was truly lovely to watch Somerville's face transform with a smile as she fed her newly bought tropical fish -- the expression and lighting made her look about twenty years younger.

But really, does anyone want to see the already-irritating Paul get more irritating by dating a slutty neighbor with a rugby fetish? I understand that they're trying to develop Paul's character (or lack thereof) but every time he's on screen, he's so insufferable that I almost prefer watching Adam whine and sulk.

No sign of Andrea and her pithy one-liners this week, but between Dr. Reid, and Sean's increasingly outlandish quest to rid himself of an infected tooth without relying on a medical professional, she wasn't much missed.

Sadly, this will be the last recap of 'The Big C' we feature here at TV Squad, since it's not garnering much traffic, but keep watching and showing your support with Showtime -- this is a quirky, original show that deserves to go the distance. Thanks for reading!

[Follow Laura on Twitter @LauinLA.]

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

3 Comments

Filter by:
Brent Todd

WHAT? This is the last recap tvsquad will be doing because of a lack of traffic? What is tvsquad now owned by NBC or Fox? 4 episodes in and you guys are giving up? Finish out the season at least.

September 15 2010 at 8:01 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Roberta

The acting is indeed terrific, this latest episode in particular well written and produced. Having watched all episodes to date, as you claim, I wonder if we are watching the same show.

Ms. Prudom's characterizations of Paul and Adam are not resounding with me. Adam is basically reacting as most American teenagers would today to what he sees as bizarre behavior by his mother. Should he assume she is dying and cut her some slack? Is that what you kids would do?

As for Paul, while he is a bit childish I don't agree that he is insufferable (though I could also do without the slutty rugby groupie plot line). Do a little role reversal, Ms. Prudom. If you are married (and if you are not, just reverse all the male and female roles in the show and examine your reactions to the show thus far), imagine if one day in the not too recent past your husband came home, kicked you out of the house with little specific reason, dug a hole in the yard (and burned your couch in it!), cleaned out his 401k (which is probably joint property in most states), then showed up with a brand new cherried out cherry red Mustang convertible after spending the day on a play date with a 30-something very attractive female doctor. How would you react? Again, should Paul assume she is dying and cut her some slack?

It will be interesting to see if or when anyone besides neighbor Marlene and the doctor will know about her cancer. I can't help but feel that talking to her friends and family about it would allow them to participate in what Ms. Prudhom describes as 'freewheeling euphoria'.

September 15 2010 at 2:20 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
davidm3825

I love this show. My favorite this year.

September 14 2010 at 1:27 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners