Andy Levy Defends Tennessee Fire Department's Decision To Allow Home To Burn (VIDEO)
by Jeremy Taylor, posted Oct 6th 2010 5:55PM
Homes in Obion County, Tennessee that aren't within the confines of an incorporated township have to pay $75 to receive fire protection. On September 29th, Obion County resident Gene Cranick's mobile home caught fire, but when he called the fire department from nearby South Fulton, they refused to put out the flames because Cranick had not paid the fee. In fact, they only arrived on the scene because his fire was threatening the house of Cranick's neighbor, who had paid the fee.The media has been just about unanimous in their condemnation of the South Fulton Fire Department's behavior. Even most of the 'Red Eye' (weekdays, 3 AM ET on Fox News) crew -- who aren't known for their compassion -- thought the Fire Department screwed up big-time.
Andy Levy, however, was a dissenting voice on this issue, and his contrarianism resulted in an epic argument with guest Angela Maglowen.
Levy made the point that not so long ago, rural Tennessee had no fire service at all, until a system was set up which allowed the cities to provide those rural areas with fire protection for a fee -- and if nobody paid the fee those areas would continue to get no service.
"Gene Cranick chose not to pay the $75 fee. He gambled and he lost," Levy argued, adding that the firefighters were actually not allowed to put out the fire "under the South Fulton city ordinance."
Maglowen's argument was that basic human decency should have led the firefighters to put out the flames.
The South Fulton firefighters have said they would have doused the flames if anyone's life was in danger. What do you think: Does Levy have a point? (You can check out more opinions on this issue here.)
- See a great moment on TV? Send feedback & suggestions to TT5@aoltv.com
- New clips post all day long. Don't miss out, subscribe to our RSS feed
