Powered by i.TV
May 25, 2013

An Open Letter to the Laugh Track

by Dr. Ryan Vaughan, PhD (no, seriously), posted Oct 17th 2010 5:00PM
Laugh TrackDear Laugh Track,

Why do you taunt me, ever so strategically placed between horribly written and executed lines of dialogue? Actually, to call your placement "strategic" is giving you far too much credit, since your existence is more predictable and formulaic than even the most basic episode of 'Saved By The Bell.'

And yes, I realize the irony of referring to a show that relies heavily on your particular form of the dark arts in order to expose you for your evils, Laugh Track. Yet, you continue to insult your audiences on all the major networks with your pandering, your cheesy repartee.

It's not that I think your case is as open and shut as many might think. You came from humble beginnings. Your ancestor, the Live Studio Audience, had some sort of integrity. Shows like 'All in the Family' and 'Happy Days' in the '70s were right to use your predecessor to capture pure, unadulterated joy and laughter from real human beings in order to give the televisual experience a sense of community, a sense of authenticity.

Programs even announced to the world that their episodes were taped "in front of a Live Studio Audience." That's your ancestor. Did 'Two and a Half Men' ever announce that an episode was taped "with a trained monkey in a control room, pushing a button when his editor tells him to?" No. Because you're an embarrassment ... to your heritage, to your audiences, to humanity.

There are situations, however few, where your intentions are pure: kid shows. That's where you make sense. Kids, especially between the ages of four and thirteenish are still trying to develop their sense of humor. It can be very helpful in their developing understanding of sarcasm, context and humor to be told when to laugh.

It's no coincidence that you were put to work in the '80s when the family sitcom explosion left no household untouched by its comedy shrapnel. Kids used to watch these shows with their parents, and it made sense for you to keep up with the kids ... myself included. You taught me well, but I don't need you anymore.

It's as if you believe that your weekly prime time adult viewers are still stuck in a perpetual state of "I don't get it!" Kids don't watch network prime time sitcoms anymore. They watch 'iCarly' or the latest atrocity they find Zack and Cody in. It makes sense for you to be there.

I realize that you are simply a tool ... literally and figuratively. Is the writing so bad in your shows that you are, indeed, necessary to make anything even remotely watchable? Or is your master's opinion of us, the audience, so low that he or she believes we won't "get it" without you?

Either way, we lose. So many shows are thriving without you -- 'The Middle' 'Modern Family,' 'Parks and Recreation,' 'Community' and '30 Rock,' to name a few -- that I suppose we should start looking at your function differently. Instead of using you to know when to laugh, we should use you to know when to turn the channel to something that doesn't insult our intelligence ... like 'Jersey Shore.'

Sincerely,

Everyone Who Owns a Television

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

10 Comments

Filter by:
hermeselling

Well written and insightful.That's actually not true
http://www.hermeselling.com

October 19 2010 at 9:16 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
sid

For shows that have a live studio, is there a sign that lights up that says "applause" or is it a genuine reaction?

October 17 2010 at 9:59 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
dkaarma

The worst thing about them though is if you cut them out, you would probably have another two minutes to put more jokes in.

October 17 2010 at 7:54 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to dkaarma's comment
Nobo

That's actually not true. When Mitch Hurwitz created Arrested Development he said he wanted it to be the first single-camera show that had as many jokes as a good live-audience sitcom, because live-audience sitcoms "have more jokes per page."

It sometimes feels like live-audience shows are slowing down with the pauses for laughter but in fact shows with no audience often have just as many pauses, they just cover them up with music or sound effects. And shows with live audiences do sometimes have more jokes because they have to keep the audience entertained. There are some no-audience shows that have a really fast joke pace, like "30 Rock," but "Seinfeld" has a lot more jokes per second than most single-camera sitcoms. People just don't realize it because they're aware of the pauses for laughter, even though the audience laughter actually gives the show a faster pace.

October 17 2010 at 8:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Nobo

"Two and a Half Men" uses an audience, not a laugh track. There are no shows on prime-time network TV that use laugh tracks except "How I Met Your Mother." Other than that it's all live studio audiences, and no, they don't add laugh tracks to save bad jokes, when shows don't get laughs they reshoot with new jokes.

So the whole premise of the article makes no sense. Basically it's assuming that all comedy should be the same - shot without an audience. But comedy with an audience is often funnier (not always, but there are as many good audience sitcoms as no-audience sitcoms). The actors have more energy and the jokes actually have to be good enough to make a real audience laugh.

It's ironic that people are always writing pieces about "laugh tracks" when there are almost no more laugh tracks (unlike in the '60s, when almost all sitcoms were no-audience shows that added laugh tracks). But remember: if you don't like laughter on the soundtrack, that's not a sign that you're sophisticated and don't need to be told when to laugh. It just means you need the techniques that no audience shows use - music, talking heads, goofy editing - to tell the audience when to laugh.

The great thing about audience sitcoms is they don't tell us when something's funny like the music on "The Middle" or the awkward pauses on "Modern Family." Instead the live studio audience tells the writers and actors when something's funny.

October 17 2010 at 7:11 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
3 replies to Nobo's comment
Manal

The only show the laugh track sort of works in is How I Met Your Mother. Correct me if I'm wrong but isn't CBS the only network (on basic cable at least) still using the laugh track?

October 17 2010 at 6:26 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Manal's comment
Dr. Ryan Vaughan, PhD (no, seriously)

Yeah, CBS seems to be the last hold out... possibly buying into the notion that they are the "blue hair" network, spelling it out for viewers. For me, it only works ironically.

October 17 2010 at 6:41 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners