The Only Thing Offensive About 'Mike & Molly' Is the Fat Jokes
Monday marks the fifth anniversary of my first post here on TV Squad. That's an eternity in this business, and in that time I've seen everything with regards to discourse on the interwebs.One of the things I've learned is that just about once per month, like clockwork, something written online sparks a crapstorm of controversy and brings out a ton of anonymous jerkwaddery.
This month's victim is Maura Kelly, who wrote about the CBS show 'Mike & Molly' for her dating blog on Marie Claire's website. The post had the unfortunate title "Should 'Fatties' Get a Room? (Even on TV?)," and in it she expressed displeasure at the prospect of seeing two plus-sized actors make out on television. The 1000-plus comments on the post (and her subsequent posts) are mostly vitriolic, calling for her firing and warning her new boyfriend that he will get dumped if he gains any weight.
But these readers are misdirecting their anger. They should be sending their venom towards producer Chuck Lorre and CBS honcho Les Moonves, because, really, the only thing offensive about 'Mike & Molly' isn't the sight of Melissa McCarthy and Billy Gardell making out. It's the fat jokes, plain and simple.
My offense at the show's fat jokes don't stem from any kind of sense of human decency or a show of support to those that are fighting the weight battle -- even though I'm a bit rotund myself. No, my stance comes purely as a fan of good comedy.
Lorre and his co-creator, Mark Roberts, have on their hands a fantastic love story, about two people who have found each other after searching for love for a long time, two people who are trying to improve themselves while negotiating a new relationship. There should be plenty of humor in that all by itself.
Sure, there can be jokes about the two of them being overweight; in comedy, no physical attribute of an actor or character should be off limits. 'M*A*S*H' made jokes about Mike Farrell's big feet; 'Taxi' had more than its share of Danny DeVito-targeted short jokes. But these jokes were selective and came out the situation or what the character was feeling at the time.
But Lorre doesn't do that. If there's a cheap joke, he'll go for it, which has always been the Achilles' heel in his sitcoms. I had thought that after a pilot full of collapsing tables and cracks about the folks at OA, the fat jokes would ease off as the writers found the dynamics of the story between Mike and Molly. Even Lorre and Roberts mentioned that the story of the couple would drive the show.
But, even as the chemistry between Gardell and McCarthy blossoms, the number of cheap weight jokes stays pretty constant, mostly via Mike's wise-ass partner Carl (Reno Wilson), Molly's cruel harridan of a mother (Swoozie Kurtz), and Samuel from the diner (Nyambi Nyambi), whose only function seems to be to make a comment about what Mike is eating (or not eating) that day.
As for Kelly's article... she needs to be let off the hook. Sure, the easy-breezy tone she used in the post, along with the paragraph that offered the same weight-loss advice you can find in a million women's magazines, made her look insensitive. But she apologized profusely, admitting that her issues with seeing obese people may stem from issues she has faced in her life. If she had approached the topic from that angle to begin with, she may have caught a lot less flak.
Anyway, I've seen the scenes where Mike and Molly kiss, and they're adorable. But then again, I've been a McCarthy fan since she started playing Sookie on 'Gilmore Girls,' so maybe I'm a bit biased there.
What do you think of the comedy on 'Mike & Molly?' Are the fat jokes necessary?
(Follow @joelkeller on Twitter.)

19 Comments