Powered by i.TV
May 22, 2013

'Fringe' Season 3, Episode 9 Recap

by Jason Hughes, posted Dec 10th 2010 7:15AM
'Fringe' - 'Marionette'['Fringe' - 'Marionette']

It was an odd choice this week, considering this was the final episode of the series until it returns next year on its new night, Friday, January 21, 2011. While last week saw the grand climax of the "here" vs. "there" struggle that's dominated much of the season, this week was a much gentler aftermath installment.

Set entirely in the original universe, on the surface it looked like a fairly typical "monster-of-the-week" installment. But bubbling beneath that was a wonderfully understated performance by Anna Torv as she struggled with all that had happened in her two-month absence.

Stepping back into your life is hard enough. Try stepping back into your life after someone else has been living it for two months.

It was little things that were the most profound. Her breakdown in her apartment after Peter opened up to her about his relationship with Fauxlivia was just masterfully framed. The tearing down of the clothing her counterpart had been wearing, followed by the stripping of the bed she'd shared with Peter was all symbolic of the level of violation she was feeling. But, to that point, it was more an intellectual violation of her living space, because the evidence of their passion wasn't in the sheets.

When she opened the washer and saw a wet load sitting there, it became all too real. Here was a load of laundry started by Fauxlivia. Including a t-shirt belonging to Peter, the ultimate proof of what he'd already admitted (thank goodness he opened up to her before she found it) about his intimacy with Fauxlivia. And the ultimate reminder, like the opened mail she mentioned, that someone had been filling-in for her in her absence. Filling in in every bit of her life.

The talk between Peter and Olivia itself was another wonderful scene, and particularly in Torv's silent performance. The single shot hold on her face as the realization struck her that Peter was talking about his having started a romantic relationship with Fauxlivia was so tragically raw and real it was heartbreaking. Her slow collapse from an awkward smile to a simple dumbfounded look as she struggled to process all that she was hearing captured that inner turmoil spectacularly. It wouldn't really be until that load of laundry that the enormity of his admission would hit her.

From there, it was ups and downs. Astrid stepped up and told her that Peter was thinking of her and that the feelings he developed were for her, but Peter had already said Fauxlivia was quicker to smile and less intense. He'd basically admitted that what made him fall in love with her were the qualities of hers that were unlike Olivia.

Then, when the week's culprit was taken in, she got another line about looking into someone's eyes and being able to tell who was in there. It was a little unfair to equate looking into a reanimated corpses eyes and not seeing the person you knew looking out to Peter's situation. After all, this was an Olivia Dunham, and not some brain-dead creature brought back to life on a slab.

When Peter looked into Fauxlivia's eyes, he did see Olivia. And he admitted that there were changes, but they were justified. He acknowledged it was a different Olivia, he just didn't think there it was a literally different Olivia. But her hurt had her speaking from a place of vulnerability and emotion. How could Peter, who meant so much to her on the other side, not know her? Not be able to tell it wasn't her?

And Peter had no answers for her. The writing and framing of that scene was spot-on. Peter's quiet "I'm sorry," after she'd walked out was perfect. As much as she is tormented, here was our reminder that Peter's just as tormented. How he must be feeling about how all the events played out. How did he not know it was Olivia? What does that mean about how he feels about this Olivia?

If, as Astrid indicated, his feelings are for this Olivia, has he blown his chances now of ever having been with her by ... well, by being with her?

The case of the week was fairly standard fare for this show. A brilliant but disturbed man re-collected all the donated organs and body parts of a young girl he'd cared for from a group therapy in order to right what he saw as her error in committing suicide. But while he was able to put her together and bring life back to her, he had only revived an empty shell.

I'm a little murky on what the marionette portion of the process was. If his ultimate goal was to have her come back to life, he wouldn't have needed a complex contraption that could be used to move her lifeless body into various ballet formations. Unless he thought it might work as a sort of physical therapy for her? It seemed, at that point, this was a diversion for himself before he took the final steps toward bringing her back to life.

The big thing for long-time fans of the show to note is that the final moments of this episode saw the return of The Observer, still observing. This time he was calling in to report that he was watching "him," which could refer to either Walter or Peter, and noting that "He is still alive." What does that mean? Why shouldn't "he" be? I guess I'll see you back here Friday, January 21 to see if we find out.

New episodes of 'Fringe' air Fridays, 9PM ET on Fox, starting January 21, 2011.

[Follow Jason @ultraversion21 on Twitter.]

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

10 Comments

Filter by:
Nuray

love, love, LOVE this show.

December 17 2010 at 5:01 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Georgia

To me, since AOL became involved with TV Squad, this site is not as user friendly as it used to be.

December 11 2010 at 7:12 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Georgia

I think Bluebloods on CBS is doing well on Friday. I'm glad Fringe is going to be on the hour before.

Fringe is one of the first shows on the DVR that I watch and keep current on - in fact, I watch it that same night.

When Peter told her he came back for her, it felt really special. Then the "rest of the story" ruined the moment. Maybe once Olivia gets past "universe lag," she'll be able to accept this herself - not just say it's ok.

December 11 2010 at 7:11 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
bruce

Well, as I feared Fox is moving Fringe to the friday night slot of death, so the show is about to be cancelled. Now is probably a good time to stop watching, having just been given the resolution to a big, ongoing plot arc from last season.

December 10 2010 at 6:23 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to bruce's comment
MrWiseguy

It's people like you that kill shows more so than networks.

As long as we get quality episodes like this I don't mind if they leave things unresolved in case of cancellation (which I'm hoping is not the case).

Honestly I'm just glad Fringe got another season after hitting its stride in season 2. Season 1 was spotty, but starting mid season 2 everything just started to click, and the writers and producers have been spectacular at experimenting and bringing original stuff to TV since then (there's few other shows with parallel narrations set in parallel universes that give the actors a chance to play out of character, not to mention not shying away from anything creepy). And, since I mentioned actors, as great as John Noble has been all around, this season most of the cast shone, even some guest stars, but I'm mostly thinking of Anna Torv and Lance Reddick.

My useless blog: http://popculture4fun.com

December 11 2010 at 9:18 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
smwvc

I don't ever really seeing real Olive react to Peter at all. She never really recipricated the amount of emotion he was feeling toward her. So when the "copy" comes up like the girl he always wished Olive to be...he'd be a fool or inhuman not to have at it. Or did I miss the parts where they were lovey dovey and in bed making mad passionate sex before she crossed over?

December 10 2010 at 11:42 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
fmd

Yes, it was a moving episode last night and the outlook for Peter and Olivia seems more gloomy than ever. But I think it's wrong to say that Peter fell in love with the alternate Olivia because of her traits. He was already in love with 'this' Olivia, or he wouldn't have come back for her.
But, I admit, it's hard to say who's right or wrong, both are equally hurt and confused.

But the final confrontation between those two in this episode has to be one of the best installed scenes of TV show history. When Peter sits there, mumbling a quiet apology, and the camera pans out to show a third chair... it's perfect. It shows that the alternate-Olivia is still there, between them, looming over them in a simple and elegant way. Perfect ending for a perfect scene, with an outstanding Anna Torv.
(Although I am waiting for the blooper reel, cause it seemed like she was laughing instead of crying at first...)

December 10 2010 at 9:07 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
J

My god, Anna Torv knocked it out of the park last night.

I saw the observer!

I wonder what Fauxlivia thinks of FauxBroyles' sacrifice for Olivia...

December 10 2010 at 8:39 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
David

My one thought is perhap Peter might have tried to let Olivia understand that the differences he saw in her he intentionally "didn't see" because he wanted to be with her and like so many others do for love,ignored the red flags even when they were obvious.I hope eventually Olivia will understand that.You can't really blame Peter for not seeing an almost duplicate that is of a person he loves/loved and had this long building connection to as a duplicate.Plus you have the duplicate doing everything she can to convince him that she wants something he has felt in his heart for awhile.

I thought this episode served as a connector to the rest of the season from where we have just come from.There needed to be a transition and this was it.Now we deal with the full aftermath plus whatever else will happen between universes.

I completely agree with the performances,as usual brilliant and subtle,spot on human and spot on to the characters,which I feel these actors have now mastered.

Here's hoping this show does what few shows have done,survive being moved to Friday.It's far and away too good,too fasinating to be allowed to die.If you are not a viewer and are reading this,please watch,you'll be amazed at how good this show is in so many ways.

December 10 2010 at 8:21 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
olddarth

Beautiful writeup Mo for an episode laden with emotional under currents.

I was hoping when Olivia got back that she would be continue to be more emotionally open. Her surprise appearance at the first case seemingly supported that hope but, of course, once Peter explained what happened, Olivia quickly fell back to her old behaviors. Sad, as she started out the episode the way Peter described Fauxlivia.

Another wonderful performance by Anna Torv. A fantastic season for her and the Olivia character has become so richly textured and layered now. Kudos for Josh Jackson too. Two weeks in a row of really good episodes for Peter.

Agree with you on the marionette scene. Its only purpose seem to be to support the episode title.

Love how the show is able to have the case of the week tie in to over arcing storyline either on a logistical level or more interestingly to me, on an emotional level.

Where does the Fringe family go from here? Lots of rebuilding is in order. Eager to participate in that journey.

Also one of the gorier episodes in awhile.

December 10 2010 at 8:03 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners