Something Pitchy: Was Tim Halperin Robbed and Who the Heck Is Haley Reinhart?

by Hilary Rothing, posted Mar 4th 2011 5:30PM
Well we've got our Top 13 and as far I'm concerned, there's a few glaring omissions, namely Tim Halperin and Lauren Turner.

Also missing from last night's results show? David Cook's boot song which was officially announced earlier in the day. Also, the mysterious, fan-selected ending to J.Lo's, ahem, highly anticipated new video. Granted, myself, Rickey Yaneza ( and MJ Santilli (MJ's Big Blog) weren't paying much attention...

However, there were a few twists and turns in this first two-hour live show that did catch our attention, like America voting in the largely ignored Haley Reinhart and the judges passing out a wild card to Jovany Barreto and passing up Tim Halperin.

Your usual trio of 'Idol' obsessives weigh in on this and more in this post-finalists edition of "Something Pitchy!"

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:

We say that the judges made a mistake but I find it very rare when the judges make a mistake especially when Simon was there. AMERICA, that's the mistake that's being made when it comes to these decisions. America has made so many mistakes in it's decisions that the name of the show should be changed to, LEAVE IT UP TO THE EXPERTS. I have seen AMERICA vote JENNIFER HUDSON off the show but look at her now, ADAM LAMBERT losing to CHRIS (whoever) was an insult that can't be described, RUEBEN STUDDARD over CLAY AIKEN was a joke that did not make me laugh. These are horrible wrongs that can't be right but thank GOD these highly talented individuals are doing okay now. I'm just a small fraction of The Idol audience but if you continue to allow AMERICA to vote in this show I myself will eventually stop voting and ultimately stop watching the show all together. It's very frustrating to watch such talented people being humiliated in front of millions of television viewers because AMERICA votes for all the wrong reasons like for family, friends and race. This is a singing, talent show and if you don't recognize talent when you hear it then somebody needs to tell you to lay the phone down and let the people who know do the voting. I am DISGUSTED beyond description----i'm out----

March 05 2011 at 5:17 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

two girls should not be in the top 12, the judges made a mistake

March 05 2011 at 1:14 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners