Powered by i.TV
December 21, 2014
TV's Best Video Clips - Updated Daily

Ignoring Orders, a Patient Wins Big and Then Loses Bigger on 'Private Practice' (VIDEO)

by Jason Hughes, posted Mar 25th 2011 2:15AM
'Private Practice' - 'A Step Too Far'Hey, Drs. Freedman and Bennett. It's TV Squad. Great call on that Tyler kid this week on 'Private Practice' (Thu., 10PM ET on ABC). He really shouldn't have been wrestling with that heart condition. But, you know what? You could have stopped it if you really wanted to.

It's a high school wrestling meet. It's not like he was wrestling the President of the United States. We applaud you for standing by the coach and telling him he needed to stop the match. But if it really mattered to you, you would have done more.

We suspect that two doctors running out there with their arms flailing around would have caused the officials to stop the match.

But no, you stood passively by the sideline while believing at the same time that what your patient was doing a few feet away from you just might kill him. Way to care, guys. Way to care.

You can go visit him at the hospital and tell him you're sorry you didn't try harder. Sure, he might not hear you because of that pesky coma, but at least you got to see him win his match, right?

Watch the full episode here:

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

1 Comment

Filter by:
jklost

As a physician who covers over 200 sporting events in a year, I am shocked by the Mr Hughes comments.
Doctors can make recommendations, which we frequently do. We can provide data, which we frequently do. We can provide the appropriate documentation to coached, parents and administrators.

Despite all of this, much of our day involves battling the same parents, coaches and administrators when we make efforts to advocate for the student athlete. This, fortunately, does not often involve life threatening issues. Most of the time it is simply over whether a kid should play with a sprained ankle.

The "new" concussion guideline have been nearly impossible to get "buy in" for. Holding the star quarterback out of a big game is never popular. We had a coach go public in the paper stating that our groups concussion policy (which was 2 years ahead of the NFLs) was "killing his program."

Until we get back to a point when the patient and the patient's support group walks out of the doctor's office, thanking the provider for doing the right thing (insetad of threatening to get a court order or multiple second opintions) we will see this time and time again.

Most sudden cardiac death issues are not caused by conditions that are detectable in screening sports physicals.

Unfortunately, the costs (1.2 million dollars to screen 30,000 students) would have to be picked up by someone.
Even doing the screening would produce false positives that would lead to additional studies.

This type of reporting is often misconstrued by the general public as being fact.

To the general public, it is not.

March 25 2011 at 6:29 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners