Something Pitchy: 'American Idol' Has Us Singin' the Blues

PAUL is great miss him!!!!!

Now that's the way to leave the show! So sorry Paul is gone, but at least he didn't act like there's no hope for tomorrow. I'm sure this was good exposure and he has a very bright future. Way 2go Paul!

WELL , my feelings on this is .. This has been the worse American Idol ever .. With Simon gone it hasnt been a contest. Jacob and Stefano should have been the ones gone last week and this week instead of Pia and Paul.. I think its A RIGGED SHOW AND SHOULD HAVE WENT OFF THE AIR WHEN SIMON LEFT .

AS far as Haley is concerned , all I can say is "HAL NO"

This is the worst season of Idol. Time for it to go...it has seen its better days. The choice of hopefuls was sadly lacking any real excitement. and interest. No one ever got honestly critiqued. Everything was just peachy keen! The direction of the program is obvious...appeal to the young demographic...under 18. Some of the contestants ...we know who...absurdly and embarrassingly overly emotional. Choice of music was boring. I for one, am tired of all the screaming and jumping around on stage..Paul's stage moves dreadful...so unappealing. Bring back Simon, a touch of honesty and a better, more rounded selection of hopefuls. Several of them should have gone home before they even started. Sad end to what used to be a great show.

I JUST LOVED TO HEAR PAUL SING. I THOUGHT HE WAS A FANTASTIC SINGER. I HATED TO SEE HIM VOTED OFF. THE SONG MAGGIE HE SANG LAST NIGHT WAS JUST AWESOME AND HE DID IT GREAT JUSTICE. I WISH HIM A GREAT FUTURE AND I KNOW SOMEONE WILL COME FORTH AND BACK HIM UP WITH A GREAT CAREER IN HIS TALENT FOR SINGING AND MUSIC.

Agree totally -- with the review!!!

Paul was the come back kid of the 70 and 80's to me....What do you expect , I knew all teeny boppers voting for young people....It's really wisdom of the generation who knows a different voice,...PAUL had that voice...The others will bottom out even after IDOL as somany have done...Not many will be talk about in 5 years...Scotty,Well Idol or not -Country will pick him up..He is a star -Country one...The Rod Stewart Days that we need again got booted --Hope someone will pick himup....

i liked paul he sounded so much like rod stewart i hate that hes gone i do not like casey to me he scretches and screams and that is not music

Paul and Pia have the most star talent. This season isn't worth watching anymore. It's insulting that Jacob and Stefano are still in the running. Really America, really?