'American Idol' Producers Considering Big Changes: Yes Please!

by Hilary Rothing, posted Apr 21st 2011 2:35PM
'American Idol' executive producer, Ken Warwick hopped on the phone yesterday for a somewhat random, though very much appreciated conference call with the press. With all the attention focused on the voting process, after Pia Toscano's elimination, it was reassuring to hear that Warwick and company are mulling over some major changes.

Though Warwick said there won't be any adjustments this season, it's clear 'Idol's' tenth year and the changes it brought, have been a learning process for producers. The world has changed quite a bit since the show first hit the airwaves, back in 2002. Here's a breakdown of the possible changes Warwick discussed and our thoughts on why they're imperative for 'Idol's' survival.

Limiting the number of text message votes

Yes, it's 2011 and we've all more or less incorporated text messaging into our communications scheme, but some have embraced it more than others, if you will. Chances are if you're not old enough to drive and you have a Justin Bieber poster on your wall, you send more text messages than I do. Nothing wrong with that, except it hands a major voting tool to a select demographic that skews the competition. Here's what Ken Warwick said about 'The Text Factor:'

"We are going to have discussions on how we can keep it fair. If people want to vote kids, I'm not going to start fiddling with the votes or do anything that's untowards. If that's the way it goes, I've just got to swallow it and maybe change the voting system slightly next year. Maybe we limit the amount of SMS votes, or online votes. We're talking about it."

Addressing the Female Voting Block

It's no secret that most dudes would rather watch 'The Ultimate Fighter' than 'American Idol' but after three male winners in a row, 'Idol's' fanbase and its effect on female contestants is a growing concern, especially after 'Pia-Gate.' I'm not sure exactly what can be done about it, but at least Warwick and company are taking it into account for next season. Here's what the EP said on the issue:

"Most reality shows are female driven either my mums or by young girls. We know we're going to get a heftier amount of female votes...case in point–losing Pia a couple of weeks ago–It's something we're going to have a long discussion about after we finish. We won't be in the process of changing anything at the moment."

Giving the judges a say ala 'Dancing with the Stars'

This is probably the most realistic change kicked around as of late, and the one most desperately needed. Reality competitions have changed dramatically since 'Idol' broke new ground back in 2002. Warwick was quick to point out the number of competitive reality shows on television, these days, when asked about 'The X Factor' threat.

"I'm not about to change anything radically to try to keep up with anything I haven't even seen yet or hasn't been proven," said the producer, regarding making any changes in reaction to 'The X Factor.' However, he did say moving to a 'DWTS' format is under consideration. "That's just one of the ideas on the table. There are a number," said Warwick.

We'll be eager to see whether or not any of these changes come into play in season 11. However with several new shows vying for a piece of the singing competition pie, 'American Idol' will need more than a pretty face and a wisecracking rockstar to keep viewers coming back to the original. For more on Warwick's talk with the press, check out MJ's Big Blog and let us know your thoughts on the potential changes in the comments!

'American Idol' airs Wednesdays and Thursdays at 8PM ET on FOX.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

209 Comments

Filter by:
Mr. Carl D. Bond

wht america, phoney judges,,stupid music critics=discrimiination is still alive

Yesterday at 8:40 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
linddar

I have always felt that unlimited voting for hours is ridiculous. It's so boring. If they actually do count the votes, it certainly doesn't mean the best singer will win although that would be the case no matter what system is used. They can all (mostly) sing if they make top 24 or top 12 whenever the public's votes kick in. It seems to be important for the contestant to connect with the fans at home in more ways than singing, like having charisma and being likable.

David Cook is best actual singer that won. Watching his performances today from his season, he seems to able to sing anything in any genre from any decade. I hope American Idol stays successful because, when the show is good, it's really great.

August 09 2011 at 1:06 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
el polacko

of course they want to add texting.. the whole 'voting' thing is just an at&t money-making scam so the more the merrier. nobody ever actually sees these 'votes' other than the at&t accountants check out their bottom line.
freeze-frame the small print at the end of the show sometime....if you can make it out, it plainly states that the decision as to who stays or goes is completely up to the PRODUCERS of the show...not you phoning/texting dupes. the oh-so-horrifying dumping of pia was the same ploy they have used at this point in the competition every season: shocking the gullible into voting more by dumping a fan favorite.. and it works every time.

April 28 2011 at 4:28 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Pat

I much prefer the DWTS limited voting format. Also, since the judges can't seem to be able to force themselves to criticize anybody, at least they'd have to rate them on a number scale. Hopefully that would prevent them from giving everybody a perfect score. That only tends to happen on DWTS as they approach the finals.

April 25 2011 at 4:34 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
tysemperfi

I'm looking at the Wendys Real Results and first of all Casey Abrams is not even mentioned. And I think he will win it all. And Haley Reinhart is a very close second.

April 25 2011 at 3:06 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
lovelylizi

Actually, I think DWTS format really works. I think that the judges should give points and we really should limit the number of votes to about 5. This way the votes would only go for their favorite. My girlfriend's daughter and her friends stay voting the entire time cause they love Scotty! He is young and they can relate to him. However, I think the clear winner is James. I have thought that from the beginning.

April 25 2011 at 12:55 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Asuigeneris1

I think the age thing should change, why not allow 35-40 year olds with powerhouse voices compete?

...they act as if everyone cares as much about the fact these are mostly decent looking kids, versus whether the talent is there.

I'd much rather listen to a 45 year old overweight black women sing me some powerhouse R&B or even over-the-hill rockers with incredible vocal and instrumental skills.

Steven Tyler is prime example, Aerosmith is still better than a good percentage of newer bands. LOL

April 25 2011 at 12:29 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mik's $ Toy

I don't care if it's DWTS or A.I., there should only be ONE voter per person, or ONE voter PER phone number. Any more than ONE voter per person/per phone number makes it a popularity contest, NOT a vote for who is BEST.

April 24 2011 at 6:27 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
smkcf

Let the people vote for who they like least not best !

April 24 2011 at 2:29 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
None

Leave the show alone. Isn't it about what the fans want and Pia didn't have fans. The show is having one of its best seasons. Pia was a screamer not a singer. Haley can sing, entertain, has personality and fans so that is why she is still there. Duh!!!!!!!

April 23 2011 at 3:58 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Follow Us

From Our Partners