Could an Old Enemy Return on 'Big Brother'? (VIDEO)

It was the twist that everyone (except Lawon) saw coming -- the possibility that Brendon and Rachel might be reunited to once again dominate the game on 'Big Brother' (Thurs., 9PM ET on CBS).

Last night, Lawon told HOH Kalia to put him up for eviction opposite Rachel, suggesting that it would be safer for him to be given a chance to return than the house's public enemy number one. But Lawon wasn't counting on America's Choice ...

With over a million votes, America decided to let Brendon compete for a chance to reenter the house, and if Kalia and Danielle had stuck to their guns and evicted Rachel, she would've had to compete against her fiancé for a chance to stay in the game.

Instead, Brendon bested Lawon (shocker!) and the unstoppable couple was reunited, reinvigorating a depressed Rachel and sending the housemates into a panic once more. As Danielle might say, "Whoopsy."