EDITION: U.S.
Seattle auditions
Does 'Idol' need to be such a "spectacle of cruelty?"
by Liz Finn-Arnold, posted Jan 18th 2007 6:31PM
Simon may have called the Seattle turnout "the worst bunch of miserable contestants EVER," but many of our TVS readers think that it was Simon's behavior (especially the name-calling) that was miserable last night. Our comments are abuzz on the Seattle post, and most of you feel that American Idol has gone too, too, too, too far. You were annoyed by the parade of loony performances over good auditions, and embarrassed and ashamed to be part of last night's very public mocking of clueless contestants that appeared to be somewhat mentally-challenged. And like you, I'm wondering if I have the stomach for the "spectacle of cruelty" that American Idol may unleash in the upcoming weeks.
American Idol: Seattle auditions
by Liz Finn-Arnold, posted Jan 18th 2007 1:21AM
(S06E02)We're in Seattle for episode two, and it is raining cats and dogs. That doesn't stop nine thousand hopefuls from standing outside all day to wait their turn to shine. By now, most of us have already heard that the Seattle contestants were the worst ever in Idol history. But it doesn't seem that bad on my end. Maybe I'm easily amused. Or maybe I'm just happy that Paula is awake and coherent tonight. Randy also seems in a better mood. And Simon is barely rude to contestants who clearly need to have their delusions shattered.
TV Squad Hot Topics
Most Popular Articles
Most Popular Tags
From Our Partners
- 'Saturday Night Live': Zooey Deschanel, Jean Dujardin and Nic Cage get adorkable
- Ryan Phillippe is CBS''Golden Boy,''Pan Am' star flies to new gig at FOX
- 'Parks and Recreation': Bradley Whitford guests in 'West Wing'-referencing episode
- Becki Newton, 'How I Met Your Mother' creators join forces for FOX comedy pilot
- TV ratings: 'Grimm' and 'Shark Tank' rise, CBS stays on top Friday
- More From Zap2it
- Whitney Houston Dead at 48 – Relive Some of Her Memorable TV Performances
- Walking Dead Preview: 'Barnageddon' Aftermath Will Intensify the Fight for Leadership
- CSI: NY Exclusive: Jaime Ray Newman Returns!
- James Wolk Enters Political Fray, Joins USA Network's D.C.-Based Drama Series
- Ratings: Shark Tank Makes a Splash, Fringe Matches Low, Supernatural Dips and Grimm Gains
- More From TVLine
