EDITION: U.S.
shelter island
How I Met Your Mother: Shelter Island
by Joel Keller, posted Oct 20th 2008 10:27PM

(S04E05) Ah... now I get it.
Now I get why Bays and Thomas wrote Sarah Chalke's character of Stella to be so incredibly dull that it invokes tears. I get why, despite the fact that Chalke has comedic acting skills to spare, she essentially played straight man to Ted and the rest of the Scooby gang. And I get why, even though Ted has professed that he was in love with her and wanted to be with her forever, it seemed like this was the worst chemistry Ted's ever had with a girlfriend.
I get all of it now, and now it all makes complete sense.
TV Squad Hot Topics
Most Popular Articles
From Our Partners
- 'Parks and Recreation': Bradley Whitford guests in 'West Wing'-referencing episode
- Becki Newton, 'How I Met Your Mother' creators join forces for FOX comedy pilot
- TV ratings: 'Grimm' and 'Shark Tank' rise, CBS stays on top Friday
- John Goodman, Roseanne Barr reunite in NBC pilot 'Downwardly Mobile'
- 'The Vampire Diaries' recap: In which Elena is starting to get on our nerves
- More From Zap2it
- Walking Dead Preview: 'Barnageddon' Aftermath Will Intensify the Fight for Leadership
- CSI: NY Exclusive: Jaime Ray Newman Returns!
- James Wolk Enters Political Fray, Joins USA Network's D.C.-Based Drama Series
- Ratings: Shark Tank Makes a Splash, Fringe Matches Low, Supernatural Dips and Grimm Gains
- Shameless' Justin Chatwin Previews Steve's Quest to Win Back Fiona and His 'Sticky' Mess
- More From TVLine
- Original Walking Dead Illustrator Sues Series' Creator Over Pay
- James Wolk Signs On to USA's Political Animals
- Watch This Shaky Footage of In-Store-Only Breaking Dawn 2 Sneak Peek
- Today, The Phantom of the Opera to Break the 10,000-Show Mark
- Now Saoirse Ronan Will Play Snow White (Sort Of)
- More from Vulture
